Cookie Heart (Giant Cookie Cake Recipe) (2024)

As an Amazon Associate, I earn commissions from qualifying purchases (disclosure policy).

Make this Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Heart this Valentine’s day! This cookie heart is the best giant cookie cake recipe! Simple and Scrumptious! Chewy, dense, crisp-buttery edges with loads of chocolate!

What do you usually do for Valentine’s day? With restaurants being so busy, and most years it typically lands on a busy school night, I usually try and make a fun dinner for our family at home, usuallyinhaled eaten in 20 minutes because we have to get across town for swimming or some athletic event!

Our favorite Valentine’s day treats are these Air Fryer Heart Biscuit Donuts, Best Traditional Shortbread or make these easy Easy 5-Ingredient Raspberry Cheesecake Thumbprint Cookies.

At Home Valentine’s Day

Oh sure in the early years, my hubby would take me out to a fancy restaurant, buy me roses and I’d get all dressed up, but I’m really not a make-a-big-fuss kind of girl.

Now I try setting a pretty table using the good dishes and crystal, sometimes I’ll even set things up on the coffee table in front of a fire, which is how we did it last year (we did talk, I promise). Changing things up is fun, even for teenage boys!

Simple Ingredients

• Butter | The real stuff, should be hard straight from fridge, but soften for the recipe.
• Sugar | White (I use all-natural cane sugar) and Light Brown Sugar is what we’ll use
• Eggs | I use large eggs in all of my baking
• Vanilla | ever made homemade vanilla, a must try!
• All-Purpose Flour | I always use organic, unbleached AP Flour
• Chocolate | We’ll use Chocolate Cips, Chocolate Chunks and Valentine M&M’s

How to make a Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Heart

I really do prefer to stay home; family dinners are getting harder to come by in these teen years, and I cherish those times together.

So I chill some Martinelli’s for the boys and I might make a special co*cktail for Brad and me, doesn’t really matter what dinner is, it’s dessert that counts! I have also made these Valentine’s Cake Pops and this oh-so-decadent Death By Chocolate Cake.

Start with my basic Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookiedough and simply replace the mini-chocolate chips with 1 (heaping) cup of Valentine’s M & M’s in addition to the regular chocolate chips and chunks. Stir them carefully into the dough, there is not such thing as to chocolatey, is there??

NOTE | You can see the step by step for the cookie dough in the link above, but the complete recipe for the cookie dough is at the end of this post.

Reserve some M & M’s for placing on top after baking.

If you happen to have a heart-shaped pan, great! Mine is actually a heart form from a spring-form pan.

OR you can use an 8 or 9″ round cake pan, nothing wrong with a giant round cookie! If you must have it heart-shaped cookie, then check out these options. 10″ heart shaped pan 6″ heart shaped pan (make 2 or three!), these tart pans are darling, or this heart shaped variable size set.

Be sure to liberally grease your pan in preparation, using non-stick cooking spray or spray oil.

Place roughly ⅓ of the dough into the pan/form.

Press the cookie dough into the pan, about ¾ inch thick, adding or removing dough as needed.

You can attempt to make a free-form heart, I made an extra smaller heart, just by pressing it into a heart shape.

Next, freeze the dough for 30 minutes until firm, don’t skip this step!

In order to keep the dip in the top of the heart (it probably has a technical name) I used a little folded foil, sprayed with non-stick oil and tucked it in to help it keep from spreading.

About 15-20 minutes into chilling, preheat your oven to 350°.

Place cookie sheet, or cake pan into oven and bake for 15-20 minutes, watching closely towards the end. Depending on how thick you made the cookie,it will cook quicker or slower.

Remove from oven when edges are lightly browned and crispy, center will still be pretty soft and gooey. Allow to cool completely on cookie sheet, on cooling rack.

PRO BAKERS TIP | Using another handful or two of M & M’s, gently sprinkle all over the giant cookie while cookie is still hot and if desired press into cookie.

Once cooled, using a table knife, gently insert between sides of cookie and pan and release from mold or pan.

If removing from a pan, allow to cool for 15-25 minutes, use a knife to separate the edges from the pan, carefully turn over onto cooling rack laid on top of pan.

Invert and allow to cool completely. If you prefer not to have cooling rack marks, using the same method, invert back using another cooling rack. Be sure that you greased your pan extremely well before baking!

Bakers Tip

Even as mine cooled, the center was still quite gooey, I wanted to move it to a serving plate, so I placed the cookie sheet back in the freezer for 15 minutes just to harden the center. Then using a large spatula it transferred quite easily to the serving plate.

If baking free-form hearts or baking smaller hearts, they will need less baking time, watch them closely. Mine did spread even after freezing, but it didn’t stop my family from tearing into the cookie!

Serve on a pretty plate or pedestal, slice into wedges using a knife or pizza cutter.

Serve cold or warm with a scoop of your favorite ice cream (maybe even homemade?) and chewy hot fudge sauce or bourbon caramel sauce for an extra decadent dessert. Which is kind of the point for Valentine’s day right??

TIPs from the Fresh Cooky | To reheat the cookie, place on a cookie sheet into a 250° oven for about 5-10 minutes until warm through.

This recipe makes two large cookies, or one large cookie and about 16 regular size cookies!

I scooped my extra dough using a medium cookie scoop. Freeze the dough balls on a small cookie sheet or plate until firm, then transfer to an airtight container or freezer baggie.

When ready to bake, allow to come to room temperature while you are preheating your oven, about 10-15 minutes and bake at 375° for 8-10 minutes.

Want to make Gluten-Free, use my Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough!

MORE VALENTINE’S DAY RECIPES

• Chocolate Lava Cakes
• Chocolate Stuffed Monkey Bread
• Giant Chocolate Chip Cookies with Fleur de Sel
• Espresso Brown Bites with Kahlua Buttercream
• Easy Valentine’s Dessert Recipes
• Starbucks White Hot Chocolate and this Hot Chocolate Recipe for two
• Easy Crockpot Peanut Clusters
• Ferrero Rocher Ice Cream

Try these other sweet treats for Valentine’s Day!

• Mini French Silk Pies
• Whoopie Pies
• Brown Butter Rice Krispie Treats (oh my!)
• Chocolate Bread Pudding with Creme Anglaise (dreamy)